Header image

Morphology and Mineralogy of Sandy Materials as Significant Trace Evidence in a Murder and Drug Investigation in South Australia

Tracks
Wednesday, July 23, 2025
10:08 AM - 10:20 AM

Overview

Rob Fitzpatrick | University of Adelaide


Speaker

Agenda Item Image
Professor Robert Fitzpatrick
Director Centre for Australian Forensic Soil Science (CAFSS)ss)
The University of Adelaide

Morphology and Mineralogy of Sandy Materials as Significant Trace Evidence in a Murder and Drug Investigation in South Australia

Abstract

Through two cases involving a murder and drug investigation, this paper will demonstrate how pedological, mineralogical and chemical investigations involving sandy materials recovered from shoes, have been critical in developing reliable forensic information on sandy materials, from landscape to microscopic scales were used as evidence in Australia.

Sufficient descriptive and mineralogical (X-ray powder diffraction) data was acquired on all questioned sandy samples collected from shoes and control samples collected from sand dunes associated with both crime scenes. This information was used in both the murder and drug investigation to determine the major similarities and differences between the questioned samples and control samples using no, limited, moderate, moderately strong, strong, very strong or extremely strong “Categories of Comparability” of being from a single location.

Murder case: Two suspects denied ever being on the beach in South Australia where a body was found. Questioned sandy material samples were recovered from the shoes of the suspects. Control samples were collected at the crime scene on the beach where the body was found. Based on morphological and mineralogical examination the questioned samples recovered from both the suspect’s shoes have an extremely strong degree of comparability to control sites at the crime scene. A jury found the suspect guilty of murder.

Drug case: Five men were arrested after locating 486 cannabis plants being grown on sand dunes in 2 locations in dense Mallee scrubland near Coonalpyn, South Australia. They were arrested at their homes across Adelaide where 6 pairs of shoes with lambswool covered soles were seized. Based on morphological and mineralogical examination the questioned samples recovered from 6 pairs of suspect’s shoes have an extremely strong degree of comparability to the control surface soils collected at the 2 adjacent outdoor cannabis plantations. A jury found all suspects guilty.

Biography

Rob Fitzpatrick is Director of the Centre for Australian Forensic Soil Science, which provides focus for development and application in the use of earth materials for forensic purposes. He is Vice Chair of the International Union of Geological Sciences Initiative on Forensic Geology. Rob has conducted over 250 forensic investigations for law enforcement agencies involving search, location and recovery of earth materials to solve forensic investigations in “high end” criminalistic cases. He is Deputy Director of the Acid Sulfate Soils Centre and Adjunct Professor at the University of Adelaide focusing on basic and applied research of acid sulfate soils associated with environmental science, mineral exploration and damage to infrastructures.
loading